Back to Stories

Custom Sticker Materials: A Guide to Choosing the Right One

Custom Sticker Materials: A Guide to Choosing the Right One

A sticker can be a whole vibe. And whether you’re a small business owner, a late-night DJ, or a high-tech visionary, the material you choose for your sticker can tell a story before anyone even reads the text. As StickerYou founder Andrew Witkin says, while all our materials are high-quality and durable, choosing the right one is like putting the cherry on top of your brand. 

Ready to find your material match? 

1. The Party Animal 🕺

Identify with: Nightclubs, EDM DJs, festivals, cannabis culture or late-night snack brands Choose: Glow-in-the-dark or glitter

Why? If your brand lives for nightlife culture, you need to be seen when the lights go down. Glow-in-the-dark stickers charge up in the light and pop in the dark — perfect for trippy cannabis brands or aliens-only events. If you want that same wow factor during the day, go for glitter. It uses full-spectrum, holographic flakes to give your art a premium, textured shine that begs for attention.

2. The Eco-Warrior 🌿

Identify with: Organic coffee roasters, wellness advocates or sustainable fashion brands Choose: Eco-safe stickers

Why? You care about your carbon footprint, and your packaging should prove it. Our eco-safe labels are made from 40 per cent recycled content, have no harmful additives, and are both recyclable and compostable. With a natural, slightly textured matte finish, they offer an authentic earth-friendly lean.

3. The Luxe Visionary 🥂

Identify with: Gourmet chocolatiers, high-end cosmetics or wedding planners 

Choose: Goldsilver or colored foil

Why? You don’t just sell a product; you sell an experience. Nothing conveys a premium brand quite like the shimmer of foil. Whether it’s a gold foil label on a high-end cannabis chocolate bar or an elegant seal for a wedding gift box, this material helps take things up a notch.

4. The Tech-Forward Maverick 🛸

Identify with: Innovative startups, app developers or futuristic artists 

Choose: Holographic

Why? You’re all about the cutting edge, aren’t you? Holographic stickers use metalized vinyl to create a prismatic rainbow effect that feels techy and modern. 

5. The Comfort Seeker 🧸

Identify with: Veterinarians, mascots or any company that wants to feel a little more human

Choose: Fuzzy

Why? Sometimes, you just want to be touched. Fuzzy stickers are all about tactility and a calming emotional connection. They’re great for pet brands or an animal sports team mascot. Running your thumb over them can offer a little stress relief when times feel tough, too.

6. The Sophisticated Minimalist 🎨

Identify with: Independent artists, artisan bakers or boutique curators

Choose: Matte or writable stickers

Why? You appreciate the subtle things in life. Matte finishes offer a velvety feel that is modern, sophisticated and glare-free. And if you’re a small-batch producer who needs to add a roast date or batch number by hand, writable labels bridge the gap between mass production and a personal, artisan touch.

Ready to find your match? Start creating your custom stickers today.

Custom Sticker Materials: A Guide to Choosing the Right One